How PowerPoint Stifles Innovation
Updated: Sep 24
A common assumption has long prevailed: a successful meeting necessitates a PowerPoint presentation. However, as organizations strive for innovation and creative thinking, it's high time to challenge this conventional belief. Embracing innovation often requires breaking free from the shackles of tradition, and in this case, reconsidering the role of PowerPoint in modern communication. Let’s talk about how this widely accepted practice might, in fact, hinder innovation.
Learning from The Columbia Space Shuttle Disaster
To appreciate the need for a shift in our mindset about presentations, we can reflect on the tragic events of January 16, 2003, when the Columbia space shuttle embarked on a mission. However, shortly after liftoff, large chunks of spray-on foam insulation (SOFI) broke off from an external tank and struck the shuttle's left wing. With this critical damage, Columbia and its seven crew members orbited Earth, facing an uncertain re-entry.
In preparation for the Columbia mission, some engineers suspected this could be a problem and produced a slide deck for NASA.
The PowerPoint slides, which were not clearly written and left room for interpretation or uncertainty, unintentionally convinced NASA officials that the damage to the Columbia shuttle would not be a significant or important one. As a result, they believed it was safe to proceed with the mission.
The engineers and their PowerPoints failed to convey the gravity of the damage clearly and left NASA officials with a misleading sense of security. This critical error led to the ill-fated decision to proceed with re-entry
Amazon's Narrative Over PowerPoint
Amazon, led by its Founder and CEO, Jeff Bezos, banished the ubiquitous PowerPoint slides from Amazon's meetings. Instead, employees are encouraged to craft "narratively structured six-page memos" for discussion. The process entails silent reading of these memos for the first 30 minutes of a meeting, followed by an in-depth discussion of the ideas presented.
Bezos' rationale is clear: he seeks to eliminate the pitfalls that often accompany PowerPoint presentations, such as complacency, inattention, and the stifling of creativity. By fostering a culture of silent reading and discussion, Bezos aims to ensure that every participant is genuinely engaged and on the same page—literally. While the quality of these memos can vary widely, the narrative structure proves far more effective than conventional PowerPoint slides.
The Science Behind PowerPoint's Shortcomings
The growing scrutiny of PowerPoint is not without empirical backing. Studies have shown that audience engagement with PowerPoint presentations declines rapidly, with most people disengaging within six minutes. In another study, 58% of managers admitted to falling asleep during a presentation. The core issue lies in PowerPoint's structure, which encourages presenters to create slides that dominate the narrative. This can overload the audience's cognitive capacity, leading to information oversimplification and a lack of retention.
This critique extends beyond the corporate world, with even visionaries like Elon Musk voicing their concerns. Musk urges CEOs to spend less time in meetings and more time on product improvement through daily innovations. He asserts that excessive reliance on PowerPoint hinders progress and innovation, highlighting the need for a fundamental shift in communication methods.
As organizations increasingly recognize these limitations, they are exploring alternatives that prioritize meaningful discussion, comprehension, and engagement. In an era when success hinges on effective communication and innovation, reevaluating our reliance on PowerPoint is a testament to our adaptability and our commitment to clarity, engagement, and progress. It is essential to challenge the status quo, experiment with new approaches, and recognize that in the realm of communication, one size does not fit all.
We are MPL Innovation, a boutique innovation consultancy.
Our mission is to empower our clients by propelling their corporate innovation initiatives to new heights.
With our specialized innovation consulting services, we assist organizations in surpassing their boundaries and unlocking unprecedented growth opportunities.
Follow us ➡️ HERE